@paco@infosec.exchange @trashwizard@mastodon.social @Em0nM4stodon@infosec.exchange The energy use argument of AI isn't the gotcha you think it is. The average single prompt to Google Gemini takes about 0.24 Wh of electricity, which is the same as running a microwave oven for 1 second. If you are comparing it to how much energy it takes to run internet searches and scour forums for however much time, often the AI will come up to using less electricity overall.
AI's environmental impact is huge, but each individual use is not nearly as huge, and shaming somebody for quickly finding an answer that they tried and couldn't find otherwise isn't productive, logical, or accurate in this case.
Of course, using these increases demand for them, which necessitates training new models, which takes significantly more energy than prompting them, so it's not cut-and-dry, but that's my point, it's not cut-and-dry.
This was personally useful for you and basically no one else.
This is true every time somebody solves a problem they had and doesn't publish the results, and the energy use of solving the problem is still duplicated among everybody who has to solve the problem with or without AI.
I'm not an AI booster or anything, but this line of dishonest argument is tired on both sides (the proponents are significantly more annoying about it than the detractors, to be fair). If they solved the energy use overnight, or built fields of solar panels to completely offset the energy use, would you be 100% OK with this AI use? Would most of the people complaining about the energy footprint be OK with it? With many of the artists complaining about copyright violation, would they be OK if one was trained on public domain work and was still stealing their jobs?
AI is a symptom and an accelerator of what is broken about our economic systems, and the capitalist oligarchy. It's not the problem in and of itself, it's a magnifying glass on the fact that the game is rigged, and we don't have the structures set up to actually keep people fed and housed who need to be fed and housed.