Remote

Ralf Bendrath

@bendrath@eupolicy.social

mastodon 4.6.9

Policy adviser Greens/EFA in the European Parliament, Civil Liberties, Justice & Home Affairs, #EUdataP #dataprotection #privacy

0 Followers

0 Following

30 Posts

Joined November 02, 2022

Website:

https://ralf-bendrath.eu

Job:

https://www.greens-efa.eu/en/person/bendrath-ralf

Blog:

https://bendrath.blogspot.com/

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to on eupolicy.social

A core amendment from Greens, which limits the scanning to specific suspects, got a simple majority of 322 in favour, 255 against, 36 abstentions. Even though this was not sufficient for the required absolute majority, this sends a clear signal in view of the on-going negotiations on the long-term Regulation, where this is part of the Parliament's mandate. The Parliament wants to stick to this line, this became clear today. (3/X)

32

1

9

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

So the main fight is now on the limitations on the scanning in the long-term Regulation. The Parliament needs to stick to its very restrictve line to not allow general #chatcontrol, but only look into communications of specific suspects. Negotiations will resume after the summer recess in September. (9/X)

27

1

15

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

Also, two amendments that would exclude the error-prone scanning for unknown material and for solicitation of children ("grooming") got a clear simple majority: 345+/237-/18a and 346+/254-/3a. Edit: To be clear, they were *not* adopted, since they failed to get an absolute majority of 360 votes. (4/X)

22

1

6

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

If you want to understand the exact voting procedure today, see the voting list here: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/sedcms/votingList/C10-0178.pdf And here you can see who voted how (point 2): https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-07-09-RCV_EN.html (10/X)

europarl.europa.eu

15

1

7

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

So where are we? Parliament amended the Council position from first reading in its second reading (because the encryption amendments were adopted). Now, Council can accept it, and then this is it. If Council does not approve the amendments within three months, we go to Conciliation Committee and 3rd reading. See Article 294 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:12008E294:en:HTML (7/X)

eur-lex.europa.eu

15

1

7

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

See all amendments here: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/plenary/en/infos-details.html?id=1689&type=priorityInfo The one on specific suspects is Greens 5, the one on excluding known material is Greens 4/Renew 31/PfE 26, part one. The one on excluding scanning for solicitation is Greens 4/Renew 31/PfE 26, part 2. (In case you wonder: Patriots copied the Greens' amendment from March, and identical texts are voted together. Greens and Renew did not table them together with Patriots.) (6/X)

europarl.europa.eu

13

1

4

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

I expect the Council to approve the encryption amendments, because this is language already agreed in the negotiations on the long-term Regulation. (8/X)

12

1

4

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

It is technically the same amendment, but the three parts were voted separately. (5/X)

12

1

3

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 3mo ago

Replying to

One detail on the adopted amendments on protecting encrypted communication: They are specifically worded to also exclude client-side scanning, which is scanning of content before the encryption takes place for the transmission: "... interpersonal communications to which end-to-end encryption is, has been or will be applied". (11/X)

8

1

2

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 2mo ago

Replying to

Update: The EU Commission has accepted the European Parliament's 2nd reading amendments on the #chatcontrol 1.0 file - the ones protecting encrypted communication. So Council can now adopt it with qualified majority. https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/document/download/95bce1fc-cd35-40f3-a5f1-93d083192524_en?filename=CSA%20Interim%20Opinion%20on%20EP%20amendments.pdf (12/X)

home-affairs.ec.europa.eu

6

1

12

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 2mo ago

Replying to

The EU Council today adopted the European Parliament's version of #chatcontrol 1.0. The signing will take place tomorrow, without ceremony. Press release: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2026/07/23/fighting-child-sexual-abuse-online-interim-measure-protecting-children-now-reinstated/ (13/X)

consilium.europa.eu

5

0

9

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

https://www.arte.tv/de/videos/123951-000-A/gefaehrliche-apps-im-netz-der-datenhaendler/ Great investigation of @netzpolitik_feed@chaos.social and @br_data@ard.social on #databrokers
This should really trigger some blast from the authorities.
Edit: Now without Youtube, thanks to @leanderlindahl@social.folkdata.se for flagging it.

Gefährliche Apps - Im Netz der Datenhändler - Die ganze Doku | ARTE

Apps sammeln detaillierte Standortdaten. Die Informationen landen in einem weltweiten Netzwerk aus Datenhändlern und Werbefirmen. Sie verraten Wohnorte und Arbeitsplätze – bis hin zu Bordellbesuchen oder Klinikaufenthalten. Die Dokumentation zeigt, wie leicht Nutzer ins Visier von Stalkern, Kriminellen oder Geheimdiensten geraten können.

23

1

27

1

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 7mo ago

The @europarl_en@respublicae.eu LIBE committe just rejected #chatcontrol 1.0, the extension of the temporary derogation from ePrivacy. Yeah!

eupolicy.social

24

0

20

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 5mo ago

We are in the same room where the final negotiations on the #AIAct took place over 39 hours in December 2023. It might be haunted - still no agreement.

eupolicy.social

11

1

5

1

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

Yess! Regulation (EU) 2021/1232 on "a temporary derogation from certain provisions of Directive 2002/58/EC as regards the use of technologies by providers of number-independent interpersonal communications services for the processing of personal and other data for the purpose of combating online child sexual abuse" https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A02021R1232-20240515, also known as #chatcontrol 1.0, just lapsed. It is illegal again to scan the content of private communications without initial suspicion.

eur-lex.europa.eu

15

0

17

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

The extension of the temporary #chatcontrol 1.0 was rejected by the European Parliament today, bizarrely enough with votes by Greens, Left and EPP (for different reasons). First reading is closed, this was it. It will lapse on midnight of 3rd April. 😁

eupolicy.social

12

0

7

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

Yay! @socialhack@chaos.social 's and my talk about the EU digital #omnibuses deregulating our digital rights was accepted for #republica26.

eupolicy.social

13

0

4

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

I will be in Hamburg on 31st March and will give a talk on the EU's Digital #Omnibus 'es that threaten our digital rights. Come join me at Nextmedia Space! The event is free, but they ask for registration. And yes, it will be in English. More here: https://nextmedia-hamburg.de/en/events/kalender/omni-who-what-will-happen-to-your-digital-rights-under-the-digital-omnibus-regulatory-changes/

eupolicy.social

11

0

13

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 7mo ago

Replying to

The results of the roll-call votes are here: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PV-10-2026-03-11-RCV_EN.pdf The amendment that limits it to "specific suspects" is amendment 5, pages 12-13. #chatcontrol

europarl.europa.eu

8

1

4

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 9mo ago

Der @socialhack@chaos.social und ich geben morgen (Tag 1) um 21:45 auf dem #39C3 einen Talk zur EU-Deregulierungsagenda, und wie die unsere Digitalrechte bedroht. Noch können wir etwas dagegen tun. https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/de/event/detail/throwing-your-rights-under-the-omnibus-how-the-eu-s-reform-agenda-threatens-to-erase-a-decade-of-digital-rights #EUdataP #AIAct #DataAct #OpenData

eupolicy.social

13

0

14

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 5mo ago

Replying to

@HowTheyVoteEU The second plenary vote had already been scheduled, based on the assumption that a trilogue agreement on another extension of chatcontrol 1.0 would need to be approved. And even if there was no such agreement, taking items off an already agreed plenary agenda can only be done by unanimity of political groups, or a vote at the beginning of the session. Both was prevented by EPP.

4

1

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

RE: @tazgetroete@mastodon.social

"Tech-Unternehmer kaufen einen Nachrichtensender" kann ernsthaft noch eine positive Meldung sein in 2026. Wow. Mal sehen, mit welcher Halbwertszeit.

mastodon.social

3

0

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 7mo ago

Replying to

@rzeta0@mathstodon.xyz No no. At the end of Amendment 1, that was adopted first, there it says "(the processing is ...) not applied to interpersonal communications to which end-to-end encryption is, has been or will be applied"

3

3

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 6mo ago

Replying to

@_tillwe_ ... und KI-Steuerung!

2

2

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 9mo ago

Replying to

@markus_netzpolitik@chaos.social Gibt es die ganze Liste irgendwo?

2

2

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 29mo ago

Replying to

@EUCommission@ec.social-network.europa.eu @zegkljan@mastodonczech.cz @EDPS@social.network.europa.eu And who will continue the EU mastodon accounts that do not belong to the Commission? Can they also migrate to your new server?

4

0

1

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 19mo ago

Replying to

@TabeaRoessner@gruene.social Ach du Scheiße. Alles alles Gute, bleib stark. Du schaffst das! 🙏💪🏻

1

0

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 37mo ago

Replying to

@markus_netzpolitik Pflegestufe 3?

2

1

0

0

Ralf Bendrath @bendrath@eupolicy.social

· 7mo ago

Replying to

@rzeta0@mathstodon.xyz It will be limited to those messengers that are not (yet) encrypted. This has always been the case.

0

1

0

0